tev0en6r

1Dual citizenship, Australian politicians: are state MPs and premiers at risk?
2Shannon Molloy, News Corp Australia Network
35-6 minutes
4
5IF Gladys Berejiklian was a federal politician rather than a state one, she’d likely find herself in a similar predicament to Barnaby Joyce.
6
7The Premier of New South Wales was born in Sydney in 1970 to Armenian parents and she almost certainly acquired automatic citizenship by descent of the eastern European nation.
8
9Armenia has the same kind of view as New Zealand — an approach that’s put the career of our Deputy Prime Minister in jeopardy — being that if mum or dad is a citizen, so are you.
10
11Under Section 44 of Australia’s constitution, being a citizen of any other country makes one ineligible to stand for parliament.
12New South Wales Gladys Berejiklian is likely an Armenian citizen by descent. Does it matter? Picture: John Grainger
13
14A cloud would also hang over Queensland Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk if she were a federal member of parliament.
15
16She was born in Brisbane’s west in 1969 but her father was born in Germany to Polish parents.
17
18He would’ve likely been granted automatic Polish citizenship, and so too would Ms Palaszczuk. She’d also be eligible for German citizenship as it happens.
19
20But unlike Mr Joyce, Nationals Senator Matt Canavan and several others in Canberra at the moment, Ms Palaszczuk and Ms Berejiklian don’t need to lose any sleep.
21
22So why aren’t the states and territories bound by the same kind of rules excluding dual citizens as Section 44?
23
24University of Queensland Professor Graeme Orr is an expert in constitutional law and explained that the states and territories have a different approach.
25
26“On January 1 in 1901 when Australia was born, it was born with what’s called a rigid constitution where the only way to make changes is via a referendum with a majority,” Professor Orr said.
27
28“Whereas the states inherited the same model they’d always had, which is a system from Britain, where your fundamental laws aren’t written in stone. They’re ordinary acts of parliament than can be updated with a parliamentary majority.”
29
30OPINION: The silly tangle of Section 44 needs straightening
31Queensland Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk needn’t lose any sleep about her possible dual citizen status. The rules for states are different to federal politics. Picture: AAP
32
33When changes are needed, states and territories can do so without too much fuss. In a federal sense, a costly and logistically complex public poll is required.
34
35In their respective constitutions, almost all states make clear that an MP being a dual citizen at the time of election isn’t an issue. Only a few have rules about a sitting member actively taking out another nationality.
36
37“Victoria is even more liberal — they don’t have any (rules) about it at all,” Professor Orr said.
38
39The issue now engulfing Canberra is indicative of the problems that can arise from having a rigid constitution, he said.
40
41Back when it was being written in the late 1890s, no one could’ve imagined how much the world would change.
42
43“The question of foreign powers was much, much broader,” Professor Orr said.
44
45“They didn’t consider anyone in the Empire a ‘foreigner’ because we were all subjects of the (King or Queen). In an ironic way, even though we’re a more globalised society, Section 44 has become so narrow that we were more global when we were part of the Empire.”
46Deputy Prime Minister Barnaby Joyce discovered he was automatically a dual citizen of New Zealand by descent, possibly putting him in breach of Section 44. Picture: AAP
47
48While the balance of power in the House of Representatives is at risk, along with the careers of several politicians, Professor Orr doesn’t consider the recent weeks of drama to be a crisis.
49
50“It’s a farce with a bit of tragedy,” he said.
51
52“But it feeds into a certain narrative that feels quite cynical. The reality is these rules are catching all sorts of people from different backgrounds and political parties. The rules are complex.”
53
54It wasn’t until a few days ago that he discovered his own kids are dual New Zealand citizens, Professor Orr explained.
55
56“My wife was born in Palmerston North during a family trip. Even someone like me, who has studied public law for 20 years and spent a great deal of time thinking about electoral law, wasn’t completely clear on it.”
57Greens MPs Larissa Waters and Scott Ludlam were forced to resign after discovering they were dual citizens. Picture: AAP
58
59The country and parliament could benefit from constitutional reform, Professor Orr said, particularly when it comes to Section 44.
60
61But the money and time required to do so via referendum means it probably won’t happen.
62
63“What I think will occur instead is that for the next few years people will be obsessed with this and will triple-check their citizenship status.
64
65“And of course, every candidate in the next election will have their family histories dug into by rival parties and the like.
66
67“Then in five or so year’ time, it’ll be forgotten again.”