· 9 years ago · Oct 04, 2016, 02:06 AM
16:40:40 PM <@DrGustave> Hi
2
36:40:44 PM <NotSurprised> Hi.
4
56:40:59 PM <NotSurprised> We b wading through worldbuilds today?
6
76:41:11 PM <@DrGustave> Bergenstahl 2 was posted
8
96:41:40 PM <@DrGustave> 5:47:09 PM <@DrGustave> Hey Funky
10
116:41:40 PM <@DrGustave> 5:47:28 PM <@DrGustave> Remember how we said to shave it
12down because we aren't reviewing a 64 page document?
13
146:41:40 PM <@DrGustave> 5:47:36 PM <@DrGustave> And how it's still a 64 page
15document?
16
176:41:40 PM <@DrGustave> 5:48:15 PM <+FunkyMonkey4> Actually Gus, it’s 66 now
18
196:41:40 PM <@DrGustave> 5:48:24 PM <@DrGustave> I fuckin.
20
216:41:40 PM <@DrGustave> 5:48:33 PM <@DrGustave> I'm not reviewing this as is
22
236:41:40 PM <@DrGustave> 5:49:15 PM <+FunkyMonkey4> I included a TLDR, because
24http://e.lvme.me/28hlutd.jpg
25
266:41:40 PM <@DrGustave> 5:49:57 PM <@DrGustave> Yeah
27
286:41:40 PM <@DrGustave> 5:49:59 PM <@DrGustave> I saw
29
306:41:40 PM <@DrGustave> 5:50:06 PM <@DrGustave> But the devil is always in the details
31
326:41:40 PM <@DrGustave> 5:50:22 PM <@DrGustave> And I'm not slowly making may way
33through 64 fucking pages to make sure you aren't breaking anything
34
356:41:40 PM <@DrGustave> 5:50:43 PM <+FunkyMonkey4> do I look like the kind of guy
36that would stick devil in the details
37
386:41:40 PM <@DrGustave> 5:50:44 PM <+Kellenredx> Hidden in there is probably "Has
39millions of nuclear weapons to use"
40
416:41:40 PM <@DrGustave> 5:50:47 PM <+FunkyMonkey4> do I look like a Vox to you
42
436:41:40 PM <@DrGustave> 5:50:54 PM <@DrGustave> Yes.
44
456:41:40 PM <@DrGustave> 5:50:57 PM <+FunkyMonkey4> *pay no attention to my
46profession*
47
486:41:40 PM <@DrGustave> 5:50:57 PM <@DrGustave> You do.
49
506:41:40 PM <@DrGustave> 5:51:08 PM <@DrGustave> Even if you DIDN'T, I'd still need to
51
526:41:40 PM <@DrGustave> 5:51:35 PM <+FunkyMonkey4> literally how am I going to slim it
53down
54
556:41:40 PM <@DrGustave> 5:52:10 PM <+FunkyMonkey4> because really, the amount of
56detail that is in it is no different from the other fully-developed WBs out there, the only
57difference is that I bothered to write it down
58
596:41:40 PM <@DrGustave> 5:52:57 PM <@DrGustave> There is no physical way you need
60each and ever detail in a 64 page document for a small settlment in the middle of a fucked
61up wasteland
62
636:41:40 PM <@DrGustave> 5:53:44 PM <@DrGustave> Look
64
656:41:40 PM <@DrGustave> 5:53:53 PM <@DrGustave> I'll bring it up with the others in WB
66staff
67
686:41:40 PM <@DrGustave> 5:54:00 PM <@DrGustave> But there's no way I'm doing that
69
706:41:41 PM ⇠@DrGustave quit (sid55753@gl-57893.highgate.irccloud.com) Excess Flood
71
726:41:41 PM Connection closed unexpectedly: Closing Link: gl-57893.highgate.irccloud.com
73(Excess Flood)
74
75
76
776:42:13 PM → DrGustave joined • Channel mode: +nst
78
796:42:20 PM <NotSurprised> LMAO
80
816:42:23 PM <DrGustave> That wasn't the smartest way to do that
82
836:42:33 PM <DrGustave> ANYWAY
84
856:42:41 PM <DrGustave> He made it even longer
86
876:42:42 PM <DrGustave> Also
88
896:43:09 PM <NotSurprised> Oh boy.
90
916:43:26 PM <DrGustave> 5:55:50 PM <@Vox> Gus.
92
936:43:26 PM <DrGustave> 5:55:55 PM <@Vox> I'm going to review Burgerstand.
94
956:43:26 PM <DrGustave> 5:56:19 PM <@DrGustave> I don't believe you're telling the truth
96
976:43:26 PM <DrGustave> 5:56:25 PM <@Vox> I'm going to Voxreview it. Not because it's
98stupid enough for a Voxreview. Because I'm going to make you READ the Voxreview,
99which will only point out potential problems.
100
1016:43:26 PM <DrGustave> 5:56:39 PM <@Vox> And hopefully there will be enough pictures
102for your short attention span.
103
1046:43:26 PM <DrGustave> 5:56:47 PM <@DrGustave> I don't believe that will come to
105fruition
106
1076:43:26 PM <DrGustave> 5:56:59 PM <@Vox> And also, because I'm not going to do it
108until Funky approves Carmine.
109
1106:43:26 PM <DrGustave> 5:58:31 PM <@Vox> Aaaaand first point found.
111
1126:43:26 PM <DrGustave> 6:01:57 PM <@Vox> Confirmed with stuff from further down.
113
1146:43:55 PM <DrGustave> 6:04:29 PM <Vox> TL;DR: Nuclear weaponry.
115
1166:43:55 PM <DrGustave> 6:04:41 PM <DrGustave>
117FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
118
1196:43:55 PM <DrGustave> 6:04:46 PM <DrGustave> Whyyyyy?
120
1216:43:57 PM <NotSurprised> Yeah, I just noticed it.
122
1236:44:35 PM <DrGustave> Loooooooooooooooooooooooooong story short
124
1256:45:04 PM <NotSurprised> Well
126
1276:45:14 PM <NotSurprised> I'll let you know my perspective on this:
128
1296:45:25 PM <NotSurprised> I'm not touching it.
130
1316:45:30 PM <NotSurprised> On the other hand,
132
1336:45:39 PM <NotSurprised> I'll gladly wade through some of the other worldbuilds instead.
134
1356:45:39 PM <DrGustave> I'm not reviewing a 64 page document
136
1376:46:05 PM <NotSurprised> Glad we share the same perspective.
138
1396:46:32 PM Vox_[Castlevania] → @Vox_
140
1416:46:50 PM <DrGustave> Because
142
1436:46:58 PM <DrGustave> Even before Vox said nuclear
144
1456:47:18 PM <DrGustave> I fucking KNEW there was some shiesty ass shit
146
1476:48:12 PM <DrGustave> But the thing that I hate most
148
1496:48:21 PM <DrGustave> The thing that makes the least amount of sense to me
150
1516:48:37 PM <DrGustave> They're obviously the remnants of the regime, and even follow
152suit in many ways to the regime
153
1546:48:58 PM <DrGustave> BUT MAGICALLY, THEY CAN USE LEVERAGE AGAINST
155FUCKING ATLAS AND ARE A TRADING POWERHOUSE
156
1576:49:07 PM <DrGustave> WHO WOULD ASSOCIATE WITH THEM!?
158
1596:49:36 PM <NotSurprised> I'd say lesser worldbuilds
160
1616:49:43 PM <NotSurprised> but they already have kingdoms for that.
162
1636:50:05 PM <NotSurprised> They'd have to specifically in a location where trading with
164Burgerstand is the only reliable option
165
1666:50:07 PM <@Vox_> Even fucking PILUM hates the old regime, and Pilum is literally
167modeled after two versions of Hell.
168
1696:50:31 PM <DrGustave> NO ONE LIKES THE REGIME
170
1716:51:32 PM <DrGustave> But they've got perfect humans and no one ever revolts and can
172sustain a huge city despite being in a literally otherwise uninhabitable area
173
1746:52:39 PM <@Vox_> Because magick drugs!
175
1766:58:00 PM <NotSurprised> Gus.
177
1786:58:03 PM <NotSurprised> If we work together
179
1806:58:06 PM <NotSurprised> we can split it up
181
1826:58:12 PM <NotSurprised> 33 page equally
183
1846:58:24 PM <NotSurprised> I got your back
185
1866:58:25 PM <DrGustave> Fuck that
187
1886:58:52 PM <DrGustave> I'm tempted to actually write out the entirety of Alapelagias so I
189could show him you DON'T NEED 64 PAGES
190
1916:59:10 PM <@Vox_> FFS, I could fit ALL OF LACANSIA in with less than 66 pages.
192
1937:13:10 PM <DrGustave> 7:09:41 PM <+FunkyMonkey4> Alright, I have a question are
194miniature, mortar-sized dirty bombs not allowed then
195
1967:13:23 PM <@Vox_> Deny.
197
1987:13:35 PM <DrGustave> My gut says no, but I have no idea how powerful those are
199compared to Dust bombs
200
2017:13:48 PM <@Vox_> Incredibly.
202
2037:14:03 PM <@Vox_> Namely because they can permanently poison vast areas.
204
2057:16:54 PM <@Vox_> [06:16:04] <+FunkyMonkey4> hmm ok. Well, poisoning the earth
206one tiny bit at a time definitely was my intention behind it, so i guess that’s that
207
2087:17:14 PM — DrGustave sighs
209
2107:17:40 PM <NotSurprised> Gus
211
2127:17:49 PM <NotSurprised> You can't sigh
213
2147:17:58 PM <NotSurprised> You're not the fragile moderator / minion
215
2167:18:09 PM <DrGustave> I'm the fragile admin
217
2187:18:09 PM <NotSurprised> That's my job.
219
2207:18:16 PM <NotSurprised> True.
221
2227:25:39 PM <AzureAzure> I fucking told Funky in my previous review that it needed to
223change.
224
2257:26:07 PM <AzureAzure> If he didn't change it from pre-board switch, just outright deny it
226for the reasons I pointed out previously.
227
2287:26:13 PM <DrGustave> He didn't change much, Azure
229
2307:26:26 PM <AzureAzure> Then it's open and closed. No Burgerstand.
231
2327:27:09 PM <AzureAzure> Not gonna waste my time with 66 pages of over explained
233bullshit.
234
2357:28:11 PM <AzureAzure> [19:28:07] <FunkyMonkey4> I made a number of changes that
236were addressed by Azuzu in the pre-reboot profile, yes
237
2387:28:32 PM <AzureAzure> If the trade issues are still apparent, nothing changed.
239
2407:28:56 PM <AzureAzure> I also said it needed to be cut down from 64 pages.
241
242
2437:29:11 PM <DrGustave> I'll glance over trade
244
2457:30:08 PM <NotSurprised> I'll uh, take a look too I guess.
246
2477:30:09 PM <AzureAzure> I don't think he understands the bigger issue though; this is way
248too big to police. A lot of this can be omitted and still not change the bullshit power that
249radiates from this whole thing.
250
2517:30:56 PM <DrGustave> HAH
252
2537:30:58 PM <DrGustave> HAHAH
254
2557:31:01 PM <DrGustave> http://puu.sh/rwQem.png
256
2577:31:03 PM <AzureAzure> Putting 66 pages of circle talking about a trade power made from
258expelled scientists and engineers on mood dampeners was already struck down.
259
2607:31:29 PM <AzureAzure> *64 pages.
261
2627:32:03 PM <DrGustave> I might waste some time and remove everything but the text and
263see how much is actually different between the two versions
264
2657:32:47 PM <AzureAzure> I mean, so far it's showing nothing from the snippet you grabbed.
266Why should we deal with this if he refused to change anything previously mentioned?
267
2687:33:07 PM <DrGustave> That's just trade
269
2707:33:13 PM <DrGustave> I hate this
271
2727:33:16 PM <DrGustave> I really do
273
2747:33:30 PM <DrGustave> It's 66 pages of over explained "drugs and power"
275
2767:33:36 PM <DrGustave> THAT BEING SAID
277
2787:34:00 PM <DrGustave> It's 66 fucking pages, and he put a lot of work into that. I'm going
279to at LEAST do the minimal amount of work I can to see if he's trying to fuck us
280
2817:34:12 PM <AzureAzure> He just got caught in a lie here, though. We brought up the issue
282with him on having the fucking means of surviving on a volcanic surface and NOTHING
283HAS CHANGED. It's still the Mary Sue capital on the map because "my nazim8s".
284
2857:35:02 PM <AzureAzure> This fucking bioshelter workaround still exists because "OH WE
286CONVENIENTLY POPULATED THIS WITH SCIENTISTS AND ENGINEERS AND BROUGHT DRUGS"
287
2887:35:10 PM <AzureAzure> Fuck that.
289
2907:35:56 PM <AzureAzure> I don't want to deal with people who have to fucking power play a
291Worldbuild and bend canon without any regard to the story.
292
2937:36:08 PM <AzureAzure> It's a fucking slap in the face to the source material.
294
2957:37:00 PM <@Vox_> Even Pilum at least is designed to hold a mirror up to the Huntsmen
296and Huntresses. All of its bullshit is taking their tools, and twisting them around.
297
2987:37:14 PM <@Vox_> No sudden "NOOKULAR WEPONZ!"
299
3007:37:32 PM <AzureAzure> Ctrl+F 'Atlas' and if it still mentions holding power over Atlas in
301terms of trade and existence, tell him to unMary Sue his nazi boner.
302
3037:37:55 PM <NotSurprised> Fuuuu-
304
3057:38:50 PM <AzureAzure> He's attempting to walk away with the idea that Burger's can
306influence/have influenced the way Atlas is, so any work made with Atlas will directly affect
307any progressions made on your end of the project there.
308
3097:39:37 PM <NotSurprised> Also, fuck how Burgerstand can deal with Grimm.
310
3117:39:49 PM <AzureAzure> Drugs.
312
3137:39:52 PM <AzureAzure> That's it.
314
3157:39:59 PM <AzureAzure> No risks because drugs.
316
3177:40:15 PM <@Vox_> The defenders offered to surrender to Atlas’s forces if Bereich
318Siebenundvierzig could remain an independent polity and Atlas could successfully lobby
319the other kingdoms to condone this arrangement. Otherwise, the defenders vowed to
320irrevocably taint the land and destroy the installation, ruining whatever value it had. At first,
321the Atlesians were shocked and offended by the brazenness of the terms. After all, they
322were in the
323
3247:40:15 PM <@Vox_> position of power. Who were the conformists to offer such terms?
325Nonetheless, the defenders stuck to their terms. Understanding the enormous value of
326Bereich Siebenundvierzig, particularly its industrial manufacturing and mining value to
327whoever could control its intact facilities, the defenders reasoned to the Atlesians that with
328the spoils of war and division of conquered lands already hammered out in a tense series
329of negotiations
330
3317:40:15 PM <@Vox_> and with the Four Kingdoms already looking forwards to vie for
332post-war supremacy among one another, Atlas could not possibly expect to conquer
333Bereich Siebenundvierzig and believe that the other kingdoms would not object to this
334tipping of the scales of balance.
335
3367:40:51 PM <@Vox_> ...
337
3387:40:51 PM <@Vox_> The defenders offered the Atlesians a choice: arrange for the
339conformist survivor’s guaranteed independence and in exchange enjoy a special, secret
340relationship with the conformists in the form of preferential economic and industrial
341cooperation, or attempt to conquer Bereich Siebenundvierzig and be left to dig out the
342defenders from the mountain installation in a drawn-out war of attrition that would only
343result in the defenders
344
3457:40:51 PM <@Vox_> destroying the location’s value and the Atlesians disrupting the fragile
346balance of post-war power among the Four Kingdoms.
347
3487:40:53 PM <AzureAzure> Trivialize the whole concept of a global threat because they are
349on drugs.
350
3517:41:19 PM <AzureAzure> That's exactly the point I made last board iteration.
352
3537:41:29 PM <AzureAzure> And it has not changed one word from the looks of it.
354
3557:41:30 PM <@Vox_> Bereich Siebenundvierzig was presented to the allied individualists
356and the other three kingdoms, but as a settlement of purely industrial value to hide the
357technological and scientific value Atlas had absconded with beforehand.
358
3597:41:41 PM <AzureAzure> So it's still the fucking same.
360
3617:42:09 PM <@Vox_> Terminating its furtive Greyed War surrender agreement with Atlas,
362Bergenstahl cut off the lion’s share of its resource exports to the kingdom. As expected,
363Atlesian politicians were furious, as the termination noticeably slowed the kingdom’s
364military buildup as well as its ambitions.
365
3667:42:17 PM <AzureAzure> Fuck, I'm salty enough to check the Docs for my posts now.
367Hang on.
368
3697:43:17 PM <@Vox_> So... "ATLAS IS SO STRONG CUZ OF BURGERSTAND"
370
3717:44:14 PM <@Vox_> Though Bergenstahl’s dust output could not match Atlas’s, particular
372the Schnee Dust Company’s dust output, by any stretch of the imagination, such drastic
373price undercutting nonetheless noticeably affected dust prices in Remnant’s commodities
374markets. This undercutting severely affected the Schnee Dust Company’s bottom line,
375prompting outrage from Atlas as the kingdom’s politicians rhetorically condemned
376Bergenstahl and
377
3787:44:14 PM <@Vox_> tried to get the other kingdoms to join in placing sanctions.
379However, with Atlas’s near-absolute hold on the dust commodity market threatened, at
380least temporarily, the other kingdoms stood to profit and were disinclined to join Atlas in
381levelling sanctions against Bergenstahl.
382
3837:44:40 PM <@Vox_> "WE IZ GOING TO SIDE WITH THE OLD ENEMY OVER OUR ALLY
384BECUZ BURGERSTANDS IS RIGHT"
385
3867:44:45 PM <AzureAzure> Yep. I pointed the same exact comments out from the same
387paragraph posted.
388
3897:45:07 PM <@Vox_> "As a result, with Atlas becoming increasingly belligerent in its rhetoric
390and threatening punitive action against Bergenstahl, the other three kingdoms intervened
391and decided that the surrender terms of the Greyed War would no longer be valid and that
392a new status quo had been formed."
393
3947:45:15 PM <AzureAzure> Should be no 'deal' between them at all. This is essentially
395saying, "Oh, we beat Nazi Germany, and will annex all this land they took, but let the Nazi
396Regime exist in a slice of East Germany and secretly have all this knowledge and tech
397they have."
398
3997:45:30 PM <AzureAzure> Was my previous comment in the document.
400
4017:48:02 PM <AzureAzure> NO!!
402
4037:48:02 PM <AzureAzure> I'm sorry, but this is a VERY huge liberty on the canon of RWBY.
404Bereich Siebenwhatever has bargaining influence over a super power because they put
405PEOPLE ON A VOLCANO and mined it first, so the ATLAS KINGDOM doesn't want to wipe
406them out and claim it because they don't want them poisoning an already poisoned
407biome???
408
4097:48:11 PM <AzureAzure> Was also another point made from the same paragraph
410
4117:48:21 PM <DrGustave> Please keep talking
412
4137:48:25 PM <DrGustave> I'm quoting all of this
414
4157:49:15 PM <AzureAzure> Nothing has changed from the original posted in the review Doc.
416
4177:49:32 PM <AzureAzure> Literally fucking nothing.
418
4197:49:51 PM <AzureAzure> He removed the titles that were never explained.
420
4217:50:01 PM <AzureAzure> That's about it.
422
4237:50:51 PM <AzureAzure> Don't fucking lie and say "Oh, I made the changes Azure brought
424up" when the document grows by two pages.
425
4267:51:37 PM <AzureAzure> No one wants to fucking read 66 pages, and it's evident he
427wants to use that to get away with everything.
428
4298:00:34 PM <DrGustave> After standardizing all of Bergenstahl 2, making paragraphs
430actual paragraphs and not walls of text with indentations, and getting rid of titles, it's 54
431pages of JUST information
432
4338:08:27 PM <@Vox_> Gus. Standardize the two documents in format and everything, then
434run it through diff checker.
435
4368:10:18 PM <DrGustave> That's what I'm doing
437
4388:10:28 PM <DrGustave> Halfway through the original
439
4408:10:37 PM <DrGustave> Wait no, I'm like at the end
441
4428:12:32 PM <DrGustave> Bergenstahl 1 is 67 pages of pure info
443
4448:12:57 PM <DrGustave> Both including the explanations of some of the phrases at the
445bottom
446
4478:17:03 PM <DrGustave> Hm
448
4498:17:42 PM <DrGustave> Original is 67 pages but 395 lines and the new one is 54 pages
450but 359 lines
451
4528:19:23 PM <DrGustave> https://www.diffchecker.com/nymhfDS5
453
4548:28:43 PM <@Vox_> I still "like" how all the kingdoms side with Burgerstand over Atlas.
455Because it's not like Vale and Atlas are close enough in the post-war era to not THROW A
456FUCKING FIT OVER AN ATLESIAN WAR FLEET OVER THEIR CAPITAL.
457
4588:29:24 PM <@Vox_> "Yeah, fuck you guys, who are one of our brother nations after the
459world war. We're gonna side with Hitler!"
460
4618:30:40 PM <DrGustave> It seems like a lot of stuff was just moved around
462
4638:40:43 PM <AzureAzure> No real changes are very apparent. My original post brought up
464all the previous issues we had in the original document, and low-to-no effort has been
465made to change this projects tacked-on nature with the canon of the story. The rules
466clearly state that Worldbuilding projects are not canon players; they don't equal Kingdoms,
467and cannot be immune to the threat of Grimm. Berghenstal doesn't just get to sit at the big
468kids
469
4708:40:44 PM <AzureAzure> table "just because I wrote 50 pages". They also fail to convince
471me why a volcano is so fucking important, nonetheless get to create all this super
472technology on the fucking fly because the means are all conveniently there. It's a bad
473case of "Look at my Huxley dystopia", that would instead make Huxley retch, then roll in
474his fucking grave twice.
475
4768:43:18 PM <AzureAzure> I really wouldn't have this much of a problem if technology didn't
477make it as easy to catch someone lying just to powerplay a location and population.
478
4798:57:21 PM <DrGustave> Anything to add, Vox?
480
4819:02:10 PM <@Vox_> Vox just got sideswiped by vertigo, so not at the moment. But I
482probably would otherwise.
483
4849:04:17 PM <DrGustave> That's fine
485
4869:04:20 PM <DrGustave> I mean
487
4889:04:25 PM <DrGustave> It's not, feel better
489
4909:04:29 PM <DrGustave> You know what I meant.