FDYZuiee

1Skip to main content
2 Top menu
3NewsPolicyOpinionEventsJobsHILL.TV
4Facebook Twitter Google Plus LinkedIn 
5Search formSearch 
6TYPE TO SEARCH
7TRENDING: DONALD TRUMP NORTH KOREA  SPONSORED: PLANET REIMAGINED
8
9TheHill.com
10Just In...
11GOP lawmaker stands by 'sluts' comments: 'I was paid to be provocative'
12BLOG BRIEFING ROOM
13— 2M 11S AGO
14Senators introduce bipartisan bill to improve IRS
15FINANCE
16 — 5M 7S AGO
17Top intel chief on statement after Trump-Putin summit: ‘I was just doing my job’
18CYBERSECURITY
19 — 7M 58S AGO
20Facebook to start removing misleading posts that incite violence
21BUSINESS & LOBBYING
22— 8M 55S AGO
23Defense Department walks back opposition to sage grouse amendment
24ENERGY & ENVIRONMENT
25— 12M 43S AGO
26House leaders clash over resolution backing ICE
27HOUSE
28 — 13M 35S AGO
29Pollster: Climate change not a top issue for voters
30WHAT AMERICA'S THINKING
31— 14M 57S AGO
32Sarah Sanders: Discussions underway for Putin to come to Washington
33ADMINISTRATION
34 — 17M 51S AGO
35VIEW ALL
36View Latest Opinions >>
37Related News
38 Learn How Renewable Energy is Transforming CommunitiesSponsored
39Learn How Renewable Energy is Transforming…
40 Justice Kennedy's parting swipe against judges deferring to administrative agencies
41Justice Kennedy's parting swipe against…
42 Trump pulls off trifecta of disruption on European trip
43Trump pulls off trifecta of disruption on…
44 Gen. Kelly should resign in protest after Trump praises Putin in Finland
45Gen. Kelly should resign in protest after Trump…
46by 
47 
48Trump is winning the trade war because China has more to lose
49BY LIZ PEEK, OPINION CONTRIBUTOR — 07/17/18 02:30 PM EDT  492 THE VIEWS EXPRESSED BY CONTRIBUTORS ARE THEIR OWN AND NOT THE VIEW OF THE HILL
504,889
51   
52Trump is winning the trade war because China has more to lose
53© Getty Images
54Don’t look now, but there are numerous signs that President Trump is winning the trade war with China. While the battle over tariffs and protecting intellectual property may eventually damage the United States’ economy, there are signs that China is already paying a price for its refusal to bend to Trump’s demands.
55
56One indicator of that price is the sharp plunge in China’s stock exchanges. Since the White House announced the first tariffs — on washing machines and solar cells on Jan. 22 — the Shanghai Index of Chinese stocks is down nearly 20 percent, while the S&P 500 is off less than 1 percent.
57
58
59That decline of share values is occurring in spite of the first-time inclusion in the MSCI, an important international index, of many Chinese stocks on June 1. That initial index listing attracted billions of dollars toward Chinese stocks, in expectation it would boost prices, but it did not. 
60 
61
62What does that tell you? Investors think China has more to lose than the U.S. They are correct.
63
64China’s government, determined to save face and match Trump’s tariff threats, is so concerned about the slide in share prices and what it might signal about the cost of the confrontation, that it will likely allow the $941 billion China Investment Corp. (CIC) to begin buying domestic stocks.
65
66The sovereign wealth fund has petitioned to change its mandate, which formerly directed it to purchases of overseas shares; since most view the CIC as an arm of the Chinese government, the move may be interpreted as Beijing again intervening to prop up share prices.
67
68It would not be the first time. From the middle of 2014 through the second quarter of 2015, Beijing encouraged China’s citizens to buy stocks, ballyhooing a booming economy and hinting that the government would stand behind markets.
69
70Stocks soared as 38 million new accounts were opened, mainly by small investors. When share prices plunged in June 2015, officials stepped in to stabilize markets; the government intervened again later that year, loosening margin requirements, putting a “lockup” in place that prevented owners of large positions from dumping their positions while also banning short selling.
71
72Most recently, the government reportedly stepped in this past March, hoping to stem a sharp selloff in share prices caused by fears of a trade war. 
73
74Another indication that Beijing is feeling the heat is that officials appear to be softening their bold “Made in China 2025” campaign. The Financial Times reported, “A propaganda directive leaked in late June ordered Chinese media no longer to refer to the term;"
75
76The FT also noted: “Chinese leaders are also seeking to reassure foreign governments and companies that the programme is more benign than has been portrayed.”
77
78Beijing is attempting to ally with the EU to push back against Trump’s trade stance; being less aggressive about dominating coveted industries is meant to help that effort.
79
80Meanwhile, it’s not just Chinese stocks that have been walloped by trade concerns; the yuan has taken a beating, too. Since the end of March, when the battle over tariffs heated up, the yuan has slid nearly 7 percent, again demonstrating the impact the trade war might have on China’s economy.
81
82After it hit a six-month low at the end of June, the government quietly stepped in to halt the slide, working through a large state-owned bank to sell dollars and prop up the yuan. Part of the currency’s weakness was attributed to a decision by China’s central bank to free up $100 billion in an attempt to boost lending and help out small businesses and state-owned firms threatened by escalating tariffs.
83
84Meanwhile, growth in China is cooling. In the second quarter, the economy grew at 6.7 percent, the slowest rate since 2016. The International Monetary Fund (IMF) projected that China will grow 6.6 percent for the current year, but only 6.4 percent next year; in 2017 growth totaled 6.9 percent.
85
86
87
88In describing the potential harm that might be done by Trump’s tariffs, the IMF economic guru Maury Obstfeld said recently: “As the focus of global retaliation, the United States finds a relatively high share of its exports taxed in global markets in such a broader trade conflict, and it is therefore especially vulnerable.”
89
90Given that exports constitute 12 percent of the U.S. economy, versus 20 percent of China’s GDP and that the entire skirmish is over disparate tariffs (i.e., ours are higher) that seems more a political message than a reasonable assessment.
91
92New numbers tell the story. China’s industrial production increased 6 percent year-over-year in June, short of an estimated 6.5 percent, while investment also was up only 6 percent.
93
94By contrast, in the U.S., economic growth remains on the upswing, along with investment spending by businesses and industrial output. A recent NABE survey indicates that business economists are concerned about the effect of a trade war, but also bullish about the outlook for growth.
95
96Specifically, they have substantially raised their expectations of industrial production, now looking for a gain of 3.8 percent this year, up from the 3.3-percent gain projected in March, and much higher than the 2.3 percent forecasted in the December survey. 
97
98Meanwhile, economists at ISI Evercore are reporting their private surveys of businesses support estimates that real GDP could grow at a nominal rate (including inflation) of 5.5 percent in the second quarter, a cyclical high.
99
100The recent rise in retail sales, up 6.6 percent in June compared to last year, fuels continued optimism, as does data from the latest Empire State Manufacturing Survey, “suggesting a continuation of robust growth," according to the press release.
101
102President Trump is rightly pushing back against decades of Chinese misbehavior, punishing Beijing for ongoing unfair trade practices and theft of intellectual property. His imposition of tariffs are meant to force a change by damaging China’s economy.
103
104The risk is that China stands firm and fails to make the concessions demanded by the White House. In that scenario, global growth will suffer, but Beijing will likely suffer most. It appears they already are.
105
106Liz Peek is a former partner of major bracket Wall Street firm Wertheim & Company. For 15 years, she has been a columnist for The Fiscal Times, Fox News, the New York Sun and numerous other organizations.
107
108TAGS DONALD TRUMP ECONOMY OF CHINA ECONOMY OF THE UNITED STATES BEIJING ECONOMIC HISTORY OF THE PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC OF CHINA CHINESE ECONOMIC REFORM ECONOMIC POLICY OF DONALD TRUMP TRADE WARS TRADE DEFICIT
109   
110LOAD COMMENTS (492)
111Sponsored Content
112 Why You Should Work at a Company Using Agile Methodology
113Why You Should Work at a Company Using Agile Methodology
114Carbon Black
115 If You Have Good Credit In California, Don't Ignore This Card
116If You Have Good Credit In California, Don't Ignore This Card
117Credit.com
118 Which Travel Card Has The Most Valuable Miles?
119Which Travel Card Has The Most Valuable Miles?
120NerdWallet
121 Walmart's Amazing Grocery Prices Are Now Online!
122Walmart's Amazing Grocery Prices Are Now Online!
123Walmart
124 Triple H and Kim Jong-un picture goes viral as WWE star comments on Photoshopped meme from Donald Trump summit
125Triple H and Kim Jong-un picture goes viral as WWE star…
126South China Morning Post
127 You could save $668 when you switch to Progressive
128You could save $668 when you switch to Progressive
129Progressive
130Recommended by
131
132Most Popular
1331
134Whoopi Goldberg, Jeanine Pirro get...
135“The View” co-host Whoopi Goldberg got into a screaming match about...
1362,914 SHARES
1372
138Mueller releases list of more than...
139Special counsel Robert Mueller's office on Wednesday released an itemized...
1402,539 SHARES
141
1423
143George Will charges that Trump...
144Will is trying to defend America from Putin, and to save conservatism from...
1451,772 SHARES
1464
147Senate approves resolution warning...
148The Senate on Thursday unanimously approved a resolution warning President...
149882 SHARES
1505
151Controversial Trump judicial...
152One of President Trump's controversial circuit court nominees withdrew his...
153539 SHARES
1546
155Opinion: One FBI text message in...
156By John SolomonOpinion ContributorLisa Page and Peter Strzok, the reported...
157507 SHARES
1587
159Russia announces new nuclear...
160Russia is reportedly testing a range of new nuclear weapons and other...
161451 SHARES
1628
163DHS chief on Charlottesville: 'It'...
164Homeland Security Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen on Thursday spoke about the...
165396 SHARES
1669
167White House: Trump 'disagrees'...
168The White House on Thursday backed off a proposal from Russian President...
169355 SHARES
17010
171GOP leader blocks resolution...
172Senate Majority Whip John Cornyn (Texas) blocked a resolution on Thursday ...
173337 SHARES
17411
175Rand Paul blocks Sanders's Russia...
176Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.) on Thursday blocked a resolution from Sen. Bernie...
177335 SHARES
17812
179Trump rips ‘Fake News Media’: Many...
180President Trump in an early morning tweet on Thursday blasted the “Fake...
181312 SHARES
18213
183Time magazine merges Trump and...
184Time magazine on Thursday unveiled the cover of its latest issue: a photo...
185301 SHARES
18614
187White House says Trump to discuss...
188White House press secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders said Wednesday that ...
189272 SHARES
19015
191Trevor Noah defends joke about ‘...
192“The Daily Show” host Trevor Noah is defending his joke about the “African...
193269 SHARES
194LOAD MORE
195Sponsored Content
196
197How Hawaii Is Building the Future Now
198VERIZON
199Video
200
201Polling analyst: GOP should be worried Trump's ratings down in swing states
202WHAT AMERICA'S THINKING
203
204Dem senator ties Kavanaugh confirmation vote to Trump-Putin controversy
205RISING
206
207Polling expert: Republicans impacted by natural disasters more likely to believe in climate change
208WHAT AMERICA'S THINKING
209
210Sponsored
211
212 
213 
214Man Who Predicted Modern America Has Shocking New Prediction
215
216 
217Rate President Donald Trump on His Job Performance
218
219 
220Bill Browder: Trump Handing Me to Russia Is 'Death Sentence'
221
222 
223Mind Control of Weapons a New Secret Pentagon Project
224
225 
226Trump Rejects Putin's Proposal to Let Russia Interrogate US Citizens
227
228 
229Dershowitz: Trump Critics 'Going Over the Top' With Treason Cries
230
231 
2327 High Tech Marvels Promise to Make Trump's Border Wall a Reality
233
234 
235Sinclair Broadcasting Accused of Misleading FCC on Merger
236
237 
238Trump, Experts Blast Turkish Court's Refusal to Free Pastor Brunson
239
240 
241Autonomous Killer Weapons Opposed by AI Innovators
242
243Powered by 
244DON'T MISS A BRIEF. SIGN UP FOR OUR DAILY EMAIL.	
245YOUR EMAIL 
246 TheHill.com
247News
248SENATE
249HOUSE
250CAMPAIGN
251ADMINISTRATION
252REGULATION
253MEDIA
254BRIEFING ROOM
255LATINO
256POLLS
25712:30 REPORT
258FLOOR ACTION
259IN THE KNOW
260SUNDAY TALK SHOWS
261MORE
262Policy
263DEFENSE
264ENERGY & ENVIRONMENT
265FINANCE
266HEALTHCARE
267TECHNOLOGY
268INTERNATIONAL
269TRANSPORTATION
270CYBERSECURITY
271NATIONAL SECURITY
272MORE
273Video
274LATEST
275DEFENSE
276ENERGY & ENVIRONMENT
277FINANCE
278HEALTHCARE
279TECHNOLOGY
280TRANSPORTATION
281INTERNATIONAL
282CYBERSECURITY
283NATIONAL SECURITY
284SUNDAY SHOWS
285EVENTS
286MORE
287Opinion
288BRENT BUDOWSKY
289COLUMNISTS
290CONGRESS BLOG
291CONTRIBUTORS
292MORE
293TheHill.com
294PRIVACY POLICY
295TERMS & CONDITIONS
296CONTACT
297SUBSCRIPTIONS
298ADVERTISE
299Resources
300THE HILL APPS
301PEOPLE
302RSS
303Contributors
304BECOME A CONTRIBUTOR
305Other Areas
306SPECIAL REPORTS
307GALLERIES
308CLASSIFIEDS
309JOBS
310THE HILL 1625 K STREET, NW SUITE 900 WASHINGTON DC 20006 | 202-628-8500 TEL | 202-628-8503 FAX
311
312THE CONTENTS OF THIS SITE ARE ©2018 CAPITOL HILL PUBLISHING CORP., A SUBSIDIARY OF NEWS COMMUNICATIONS, INC.
313
314Opinion: One FBI text message in Russia probe that should alarm every AmericanREAD NEXT: Opinion: One FBI text message in Russia probe that should alarm every American